. .

(. 1956) - - , , . , : | | | | | | .

, , (1918-1988)- …

.

, , (1918-1988) - , , , . : “ ?” :  « . , . (Agnostic for me would be trying to weasel out and sound a little nicer than I am about this.)» , , ? - , . , “ ”, 1965 :

“ , , , " , -, ". , , . . , , , , , , . , , , . - , - , , . : " ". . . , , , . , , , . . " ". . . , , . , , .”

, , . - , , , . , , , . , , , , « », . - “ ”? - , , , ? - , , , , - ? - ? , : “ , , , " , -, ".” , ! , , , . , . , … , - , . , ? ? -? , - - - “ ”!, , , , , ? : , , , , - , “ ”. , , , - , , , ? , , ?

? , - ? - , , ? , - , ? , ? , , , , , , , , . , , , . - , . , . .   

, , , . « », , .

«Turning to the third aspect of religion – the inspirational aspect – brings me to the central question that I would like to present to this imaginary panel. The source of inspiration today – for strength and for comfort–in any religion is very closely knit with the metaphysical aspect; that is, the inspiration comes from working for God, for obeying his will, feeling one with God. Emotional ties to the moral code – based in this manner  – begin to be severely weakened when doubt, even a small amount of doubt, is expressed as to the existence of God; so when the belief in God becomes uncertain, this particular method of obtaining inspiration fails. I don’t know the answer to this central   problem – the problem of maintaining the real value of religion, as a source of strength and of courage to most men, while, at the same time, not requiring an absolute faith in the metaphysical aspects. Western civilization, it seems to me, stands by two great heritages. One is the scientific spirit of adventure  –  the adventure into the unknown, an unknown which must be recognized as being unknown in order to be explored; the demand that the unanswerable mysteries of the universe remain unanswered; the attitude that all is uncertain; to summarize it – the humility of the intellect. The other great heritage is Christian ethics–the basis of action on love, the brotherhood of all men, the value of the individual – the humility of the spirit… How can we draw inspiration to support these two pillars of Western civilization so that they may stand together in full vigor, mutually unafraid? Is this not the central problem of our time?»   (The Pleasure of Finding Things Out: The Best Short Works of Richard P. Feynman, Helix Books, p. 257)

:

« [ - ], , , . , , ; , , , . , , , ; , , . - , , . , , . (adventure) - , (unknown), ; , (unanswerable) ; ; - . , , , - . , , ? ?»

, , , - ! , , . , , , , - , unanswerable, .   , , , , « », . unanswerable, , ? , , . , , , , . - , , -, yet unknown, but answerable. - . . , , ; , unanswerable, . , unanswerable, ? , , unknown but answerable? ? , he does not answer. , , -, .

, unanswerable, . , , . , , , , . , . , , . : « , ». , , , ; , , . , . “Shut up and calculate - ”, , . . « » .   

..

; , , (1916-2009). ( ):  

«… - , - , .. , …. : “ , ”. , , , …. , - , … , , , -, , . , . , (“, ”). , … , . , , , …. , , »

« 1929 , , : " , , , ". (1612-1677) , . , , , , , , XVII .»

« , . , , . , …. , .»

, - . , , - , . , … , , , . , .

, , « ». , , ? , , , ? , , , , , ? , . , ( , ) , , , , Natura naturans, , , , , , , , Natura Naturata, , , , , ?

, ; , , , , . , , , , , , - , , ? , , , ? , : , , , . , - ? ? …

, , , , , , . « [ ], … , », . , . , , , , , . « », , , :

«- . . , . : « . , , . , » (New York Times, 23 2005 .).»

. , -, « », « ». , , , . , « » , , , , , - , , , , - . , , , , , -. : , - , , , . , , . , , , .

, . , . , , , , . . . . , - . , , , , , , . , - , , , . , , , . , "" , . , : - -, , .

, , . ! , , , , - : « , », (“Facing Up”, 2001). , . , , , .

, ? , , . (, , ), , , , .

- , , , ; . , , , , : , ; , - ? - - , , - - . ? - - ? ? - - , .



, , , . ? - - , . , ; . , . ?,  -  , - . , , . , . . , , , . . , , , , , , , , … . , , , .    

, - . , , , . , , . , , . ; , . - - , . , - .

: –